PayJay

PayJay is the slash ship between Paper and OJ from the Inanimate Insanity fandom.

Canon
 Inanimate Insanity 1 

Paper and OJ had very minimal interactions in the first few episodes due to Paper being the first character to be eliminated. They were also on different teams. When OJ and Salt found out that a member from idiotic island was going to join, OJ suggested that Paper should be on their team instead of Pepper. When Paper came back to the game in episode 10, everything changed. He joined OJ’s team (Team Chickenleg) in that episode.

OJ breaks up his alliance due to him not being able to stand Bomb. When OJ was forming his alliance, Paper desperately wanted

In episode 11, while Paper and OJ were in a boat together, Paper noticed how OJ was upset. OJ told Paper about how he’s upset over how Bomb betrayed him in the last contest. Paper understands him and talks about how Knife betrayed him too. Paper says that they’ll stick together and that he’ll be there for OJ. When OJ said the word “idiotic island,” he had triggered Paper. That caused him to throw OJ out of the boat. Obviously, he didn’t mean it.

In episode 12, both OJ and Paper express their dislikes of MePhone making everything how it was in the first episode for the 1 year anniversary.

In episode 13, OJ started to notice how Papers mental health wasn’t going so well. He had found out that Paper has trauma from idiotic island and that made him have an alter-ego, named Evil Paper. When Paper passes out during the challenge, OJ is worried for him and tries to wake him up. Thankfully, he did wake up. He had heated his alter-ego Evil Paper. OJ attempts to help Paper with his problem and everything is now solved. OJ congratulates him.

Fanon
While though PayJay may be a popular ship somehow, there isn’t much fanon stuff that fans have created for them.